Beverley J. Evans.
Dynamic Display of Spatial Data-Reliability: Does it Benefit the Map User?.
In Computers & Geosciences, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 409--422, 1997.

Links:

Abstract:

As users of maps we are dependent upon their veracity and by extension the reliability of the data they contain. Several research projects have explored possible methods of visually representing data certainty, a kind of metadata; methods considered include depicting the metadata as a map that is separate from the data map, imbedding the metadata into the data map, and creating an interactive environment allowing simultaneous viewing of both data and metadata. A practical consideration, as we develop methods for graphic depiction of data reliability, is the reaction to and acceptance of proposed methods by the map user. This research studied how maps containing graphically depicted reliability information are used. Potential "usability" of the cartographic display of data reliability is explored by the type of map user (novices versus experts, and males versus females) and the type of map use (assessment of map reliability, confidence in data reliability assessments, and ability to judge the proportion of the areas within the map containing highly reliable data). This study addressed these issues by exploring and analyzing subject responses to an interactive cartographic display of data and its level of reliability. The graphic depiction of reliability information was found to be accessible and comprehensible by all subjects; novice or expert, and male or female. Two methods of combining data and reliability information, as a composite static display and as an animation, were both found to be helpful by the subjects tested. Two other methods of obtaining reliability information, a map displaying only reliability information and an interactive "toggling" between the data and reliability information were not found to be as efficient or effective as the combination methods.

Bibtex:

@Article{        evans:1997:DDSD,
  author = 	 {Beverley J. Evans},
  title = 	 {Dynamic Display of Spatial Data-Reliability: Does it Benefit the Map User?},
  journal = 	 {Computers \& Geosciences},
  year = 	 {1997},
  volume = 	 {23},
  number = 	 {4},
  pages = 	 {409--422},
  month = 	 {May},
}

Images:

References:

M.K. Beard, B.P. Buttenfield, S.B. Clapham Visualization of spatial data quality: Scientific Report for the Specialist Meeting, NCGIA Technical Paper, 91-26, ACSM-ASPRS Annual Convention, Santa Barbara, California, v. 10 (1991), pp. 423-427 v.6, Auto-Carto
K. Beard, W. Mackaness Visual access to data quality in geographic information systems Cartographica, v. 30 (no. 2-3) (1993), pp. 37-44
C. Brewer Color use guidelines for mapping and visualization A.M. MacEachren, D.R.F. Taylor (Eds.), Visualization in Modern Cartography, Elsevier, New York (1994), pp. 123-147
C. Brewer Guidelines for use of the perceptual dimensions of color for mapping and visualization Proc. Intern. Soc. Optical Engineering (SPIE), v. 2171 (1994), pp. 54-63
B. Buttenfield Representing data quality Cartographica, v. 30 (no. 2-3) (1993), pp. 1-6
B. Buttenfield, M.K. Beard Graphical and geographical components of data quality H.M. Hearnshaw, D.J. Unwin (Eds.), Visualization in Geographical Information Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1994), pp. 150-157
P.F. Fisher Visualizing uncertainty in soil maps by animation Cartographica, v. 30 (no. 2-3) (1993), pp. 20-27
P.P. Gilmartin Maps, mental imagery, and gender in the recall of geographical information American Cartographer, v. 13 (no. 4) (1986), pp. 335-344
P.P. Gilmartin, J.C. Patton Comparing the sexes on spatial abilities: map-use skills Ann. Association of American Geographers, v. 74 (no. 4) (1984), pp. 605-619
M. Goodchild, B. Buttenfield, J. Wood Introduction to visualizing data validity H.M. Hearnshaw, D.J. Unwin (Eds.), Visualization in Geographical Information Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1994), pp. 141-149
M. Goodchild, L. Chih-Chang, Y. Leung Visualizing fuzzy maps H.M. Hearnshaw, D.J. Unwin (Eds.), Visualization in Geographical Information Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1994), pp. 158-167
A.M. MacEachren Visualizing uncertain information Cartographic Perspectives, v. 13 (1992), pp. 10-19
A.M. MacEachren Time as a cartographic variable H.M. Hearnshaw, D.J. Unwin (Eds.), Visualization in Geographical Information Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1994), pp. 115-130
A.M. MacEachren, D. Howard, M. Von Wyss, D. Askov, T. Taormino Visualizing the health of Chesapeake Bay: an uncertain endeavor American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing/American Congress on Surveying and Mapping, GIS-LIS Proc, Bethesda, Maryland, v. 1 (1993), pp. 449-458
M. McGranahan A cartographic view of spatial data quality Cartographica, v. 30 (no. 2-3) (1993), pp. 8-19
C. McGuinness, A. van Wersch, P. Stringer User differences in a GIS environment: a protocol study Proc. Intern. Cartographic Conference, Cologne, Germany (1993), pp. 478-485
H. Moellering The proposed standard for digital cartographic data American Cartographer, v. 15 (no. 1) (1988), pp. 9-142ed
M. Monmonier Authoring graphic scripts: experiences and principles Cartography and GIS, v. 19 (no. 4) (1992), pp. 247-260
M. Monmonier, M. Gluck Focus groups for design improvement in dynamic cartography Cartography and Geographic Information Systems, v. 21 (no. 1) (1994), pp. 37-47
NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology) Federal Information Processing Standard, Publication 173U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington D.C (1992) variously paged
L.M. Potash Design of maps and map-related research Human Factors, v. 19 (no. 2) (1977), pp. 139-150
P. Rheingans, B. Tebbs A tool for dynamic explorations of color mappings Computer Graphics, v. 24 (no. 2) (1990), pp. 145-146
F.J.M. van der Wel, R.M. Hootsman, F.J. Ormeling Visualization of data quality A.M. MacEachren, D.R.F. Taylor (Eds.), Visualization in Modern Cartography, Elsevier, New York (1994), pp. 313-331
J.K. Wright Map makers are human: American Cartographic Society of New York reprinted in Cartographica, Monograph, 19 (1942), pp. 8-25 1977